The ideas that keep coming at 2am.

Getting Started · 5 min read

I had a client whose app started as a simple messaging tool. Clean, focused, one core job. By the third meeting it had grown to include corporate wellness modules, integration with mental health organisations, and a fully customisable colour theming system.

Another client kept adding vehicle types and insurance edge cases every time we spoke. Every meeting started with "I had another thought last night" and then the feature list got longer.

This happens constantly. And I'm not going to tell you to stop thinking. The ideas at 2am aren't the problem. The problem is when every one of them gets a seat at the version one table.

Your brain is doing exactly what it should

There's actually research on this. A meta-analysis by Sio and Ormerod across 117 studies found that stepping away from a problem genuinely improves creative problem solving. Your brain keeps working on things in the background. That's why the shower, the drive, and the 2am ceiling stare are so productive.

So the creative overflow isn't a flaw. It's your subconscious processing the problem from angles you haven't consciously explored yet. The feature you dream up at 2am might actually be brilliant. But it might also be a tangent that derails the whole project if you try to cram it into the first release.

The trick isn't to suppress the ideas. It's to give them somewhere to live that isn't your MVP scope.

The version two list changes everything

I tell every client to keep a version two list. It can be a note on your phone, a shared doc, a Slack message to yourself. The format doesn't matter. What matters is that every idea gets written down but not every idea gets built right now.

When you write down the 2am idea, something shifts. You stop carrying it around in your head. You stop worrying you'll forget it. And in the morning, you can look at it with fresh eyes and ask the real question. Does this belong in version one, or can it wait?

Nine times out of ten, it can wait. And that's not a loss. That's a roadmap forming. You're not throwing ideas away. You're sequencing them.

Let the morning sort them

The energy you feel at 2am is real. The idea feels urgent and important and like it has to happen now. But urgency at 2am is not the same as priority in the light of day. The best clients I work with have learned to capture fast and evaluate slow.

Write it down. Go back to sleep. Then in the morning, or in our next meeting, bring it up. We'll talk through whether it strengthens the core product or adds complexity that version one doesn't need yet. Most of the time, the idea is good. It's just early.

Your creative brain is one of the best tools you have. Just don't let it steer the budget.

Sources
Does Incubation Enhance Problem Solving? (Sio & Ormerod, 2009, Psychological Bulletin) - Meta-analysis of 117 studies confirms that stepping away from a problem genuinely improves creative solutions.

Related blog posts:

The difference between a feature and a solution →

You've been thinking about this for years →

What is an MVP? →